Race Realism Isnt Realistic and It Isnt Good Science

Modern genetics and evolutionary biology have reached a firm consensus: there is no evidence to support the claim that innate racial differences account for variations in human intelligence. Despite this, the resurgence of "race science"—often rebranded as "race realism"—has found a foothold in fringe political discourse and specific segments of academia. By misinterpreting complex genetic data and relying on methodologically flawed databases, proponents of these views are increasingly influencing political rhetoric and social media propaganda.
The recent public focus on these issues stems from high-profile political commentary. At the World Economic Forum in Davos, former US President Donald Trump stated that individuals from Somalia possess low IQs, asserting, "I always say these are low-IQ people." This followed a 2024 incident where Donald Trump Jr. made similar disparaging remarks regarding Haitian migrants. These comments are not isolated outbursts; they align with a broader, coordinated effort to reintroduce biological determinism into the public consciousness, challenging the scientific consensus established over the last 70 years.
A Chronology of the Resurgence
The re-emergence of these narratives follows a distinct trajectory over the past decade. While eugenics and racial hierarchy theories were largely pushed to the margins following the atrocities of World War II, the 21st century has seen a tactical shift.
- 1930s–1960s: The Pioneer Fund is established in the US, explicitly designed to fund research into racial differences and oppose desegregation. Its influence persists through the mid-century, providing a financial bedrock for "race science" journals.
- 1960s–1980s: Journals like Mankind Quarterly serve as a primary venue for academics whose work is rejected by mainstream biological publications.
- 2010s: The "London Conference on Intelligence" is held secretly at University College London, bringing together academics and fringe theorists to discuss hereditarianism without public or institutional oversight.
- 2018: University College London launches an investigation after the secret conferences are exposed, leading to a permanent ban on such events on their premises.
- 2024–2025: Public rhetoric from the Trump family brings the discourse into mainstream political debate. High-profile controversies involving academics like Nathan Cofnas, who accused the late Jason Arday of plagiarism while promoting hereditarian views, highlight the ongoing tension between "academic freedom" and the dissemination of debunked theories.
The Genetic Reality: Beyond the Myth
The central argument of "race realists" is hereditarianism—the belief that genetic factors, rather than environment, dictate intelligence and behavior across racial lines. However, modern genomics refutes this. In the 1970s, Richard Lewontin demonstrated that human genetic variation is significantly higher within groups than between them. Modern analysis of ancient DNA has confirmed that human history is one of constant migration and intermingling, rendering the concept of "pure" racial bloodlines biologically meaningless.
Geneticists note that while physical traits like skin tone, hair texture, or lactase persistence vary, these are adaptations to environmental pressures, not markers of innate intellectual capacity. For instance, the genetic variants for light skin color—often cited by white supremacists as a hallmark of European "superiority"—actually trace their origins to early African populations. The idea that human intelligence evolved in separate, distinct "racial" silos ignores the fact that human social and cognitive evolution was a collective, species-wide development.

Methodological Flaws in IQ Research
The bedrock of the "race science" argument often relies on the "National IQ" database—a collection of data points that researchers have repeatedly debunked. The methodology used to construct this database is considered by many in the scientific community to be deeply flawed. Critics argue that IQ tests are inherently biased toward cultures with high exposure to formal Western education and specific linguistic structures.
Furthermore, the "Flynn Effect"—the observed, rapid increase in IQ scores throughout the 20th century—demonstrates that intelligence metrics are highly susceptible to environmental factors such as nutrition, health, and schooling. If intelligence were primarily genetic, such a dramatic shift over a few generations would be impossible.
The "social brain hypothesis" provides a more robust framework for understanding human intelligence. It suggests that our intellectual abilities evolved to navigate the complexities of social life, cooperation, and group dynamics—challenges that were universal to all human populations, regardless of their geographical location.
Institutional Impacts and Gatekeeping
The persistence of race science in academia is largely due to a "community project" structure. While reputable journals in genetics and evolutionary biology almost universally reject race-science papers, the movement has successfully infiltrated specific subfields in psychology and evolutionary psychology.
By establishing their own networks, mentorship programs, and magazines—such as Aporia—these groups have managed to keep their ideas in circulation. These publications often present eugenics as a "distasteful but necessary" solution to global economic disparities, effectively framing scientific racism as a policy recommendation.
The involvement of private funding, such as the support once provided by tech entrepreneur Andrew Conru, has provided these networks with a financial lifeline that operates outside the traditional grant-review processes of universities. When these institutions are pressured by external stakeholders or political actors, as seen in the intervention of the US Ambassador to Belgium regarding the hiring practices of Ghent University, it complicates the efforts of universities to maintain academic standards.

The Broader Implications
The promotion of these pseudoscientific theories has tangible, real-world consequences. By framing systemic inequality—such as poverty, lack of education, or poor health outcomes—as the result of "innate" deficiencies, proponents of race realism provide a justification for the removal of social safety nets and the erosion of civil rights protections.
History has shown that when these narratives become mainstream, they serve as the ideological precursor to discriminatory policies. From the sterilization programs of the early 20th century to the systemic exclusion of minority groups in housing and employment, the adoption of "scientific" racism has repeatedly led to the marginalization of vulnerable populations.
As society continues to navigate the complexities of globalization and migration, the distinction between rigorous science and ideologically driven pseudoscience becomes critical. The consensus among legitimate evolutionary behavioral scientists remains clear: while individuals possess unique traits, humanity as a whole is cognitively equivalent. The behavioral diversity observed across the globe is a testament to our species’ remarkable ability to adapt to diverse environments through culture and social learning, not through fundamental, innate racial differences.
In the final analysis, the push for "race realism" is not a pursuit of truth, but a political strategy. By misusing the authority of science, these groups aim to influence the public and policy-makers, potentially setting the stage for a reversal of decades of progress in human rights and equality. Maintaining a high standard for what qualifies as legitimate scientific inquiry is, therefore, not just an academic concern, but a democratic necessity.







